The fate of the historic Liberty Theater in Downtown Libertyville is again in the spotlight as the village board prepares to review a redevelopment proposal on Tuesday. The plan, which has been discussed for nearly a year, aims to breathe new life into the 1.2-acre site at 708 N. Milwaukee Ave., including the shuttered theater and adjacent properties.
Proposal Details
Vee Enterprise, representing the property owner, has submitted plans that include:
- Repurposing the former Liberty Theater for retail and restaurant use
- Constructing a single-story commercial building to the north
- Erecting a three-story apartment building to the south
The proposal, which remains unchanged from previous submissions, seeks to revitalize a key entry point to Downtown Libertyville, IL while addressing the theater’s four-year vacancy issue.
Historic Preservation Concerns
The Liberty Theater, built in 1937, stands as a significant landmark within Libertyville’s historic district. As such, any exterior modifications require a certificate of appropriateness. This requirement has led to extensive discussions regarding the architectural style of the proposed redevelopment
Initially presented with a modern design, the plans have undergone revisions to better align with the theater’s Art Deco roots. However, concerns persist about whether the current proposal adequately reflects the historical character of the Liberty Theater and its surroundings.
Community and Official Reactions
While village officials have generally supported the concept of redeveloping the theater and adjoining property, the specifics of the plan have met with resistance. Both the Advisory Historic Preservation Commission and the Appearance Review Commission have recommended the denial of the current proposal.
Key points of contention include:
- The importance of preserving the theater’s historical elements
- Ensuring the new structures fit the style and character of Downtown Libertyville
- Balancing modernization with respect for the site’s heritage
Community members have expressed support for redevelopment but emphasize the desire to maintain the historical integrity of the original Liberty Theater. There is a strong push for incorporating more architectural elements consistent with the 1937 design.
Next Steps
The village board now faces a crucial decision. They have three options:
- Accept the plan as submitted
- Deny the proposal
- Approve it with conditions
If denied, the property owners would need to restart the review process should they wish to pursue redevelopment.
Challenges and Considerations
The Liberty Theater redevelopment project highlights the complex balance between progress and preservation in Downtown Libertyville. The site’s prominent location at the entrance to the downtown area amplifies the importance of achieving a design that enhances the community while respecting its historical context.
Additionally, the property owner’s previous lack of responsiveness has been a point of concern for village officials, adding another layer of complexity to the negotiations.
Looking Ahead
As the village board prepares to convene, the future of the Liberty Theater hangs in the balance. The decision made on Tuesday could set the stage for a transformative project in Downtown Libertyville or send developers back to the drawing board.
The meeting, scheduled for 8 p.m. at the village hall (118 W. Cook Ave.), promises to be a pivotal moment in the ongoing saga of the Liberty Theater redevelopment. Residents, business owners, and history enthusiasts alike will be watching closely as Libertyville weighs the merits of progress against the value of preserving a cherished piece of local heritage.
